How Speech Contests Are Judged
Speech contests are judged by people listening once, in real time, so the sheet has to be quick to fill in and clear about what each point is for. Publish the criteria, the time window and the tie rule with the entry form, so speakers prepare for the same contest the judges are scoring.
| Format | Usually run by | How it is judged |
|---|---|---|
| Prepared speech | Schools, clubs, associations | Speaker's own topic or a set theme, scored on content and delivery |
| Oratorical contest | Civic groups, foundations, schools | Memorized speech on a set theme, content weighted higher |
| Impromptu speech | Clubs and school leagues | A topic given on the spot, short prep, scored on structure and poise |
| Persuasive or policy speech | Schools, youth programs | A clear position, evidence and a call to action |
| Youth or classroom contest | Teachers, libraries, youth groups | Shorter speeches, encouraging comments, simpler sheet |
If speakers face each other on a resolution, use the debate judging sheet instead. For written entries, see the essay contest judging rubric, and for business pitches, the pitch competition judging criteria. If your contest is part of a series run by a club or organization with its own official forms, use those.
Speech Contest Judging Criteria and Rubric
Six criteria make a 100-point speech competition rubric. The weights are an example, not a standard; shift points to content for an oratorical contest or to delivery for an open contest.
| Criterion | What judges look for | Points |
|---|---|---|
| Content and message | A clear purpose, a strong central idea, relevant examples, fits the theme | 25 |
| Organization | An opening that hooks, a logical flow, a memorable close | 15 |
| Vocal delivery | Clear, audible voice, varied pace and tone, few filler words | 20 |
| Body language and presence | Eye contact, posture, purposeful gestures, confidence | 15 |
| Language | Vivid, accurate word choice suited to the audience | 15 |
| Time and rules | Within the time window, on topic, follows notes and prop rules | 10 |
| Total | All criteria | 100 |
| Level | Share of the criterion's points | Example on a 25-point criterion |
|---|---|---|
| Excellent | 90 to 100 percent | 23 to 25 |
| Strong | 75 to 89 percent | 19 to 22 |
| Developing | 60 to 74 percent | 15 to 18 |
| Beginning | Under 60 percent | Under 15 |
Printable Speech Contest Judging Sheet
Print one sheet per judge per round, plus a timing sheet for the timekeeper and a tally for the scorekeeper. Score by speaking order number.
Speech Contest Rules and How to Run the Day
- 1
Publish the rules and criteria
Publish the rules, the theme, the time window and the criteria with the entry form, and send judges the sheet a week ahead.
- 2
Set the order and the rooms
Draw the speaking order at check-in and post it outside the room. Give speakers a warm-up room and a volunteer who brings them in.
- 3
Brief the officials
Brief judges, the timekeeper and the scorekeeper for five minutes before the first speaker. Seat judges apart.
- 4
Score and check
Collect sheets after each speaker or at the end of the round, total them with a second person and keep the results sealed until the announcement.
- 5
Announce the winners
Announce places from the stage and hand speakers their comments. The award ceremony script has wording you can adapt.
Judge Instructions and Tie-Breakers
| Method | How it works | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Higher content score | The speaker with more content and message points wins | Most contests |
| Sum of judges' ranks | Each judge ranks speakers; the lowest total wins | Panels of three or five judges |
| Majority of first places | The speaker ranked first by more judges wins | Finals |
| Chief judge decides | A non-scoring chief judge picks between the tied speakers | Last step when all else is equal |
Planning the event around the contest? The run of show template times speakers, breaks and the awards, and community event software covers the venue map, sponsors and the app.