Skip to main content
Poetry Slam Planning

Poetry Slam Judging Criteria & Score Sheet

A printable poetry slam judge card and scorekeeper sheet, the common 0 to 10 scale with dropped high and low scores, time penalties, a calibration poet, host script and tie-breaks.

How a Poetry Slam Works

A poetry slam is a competition in which poets perform original work and judges from the audience score it. The format below is the common one at open mics, school and library slams, and festival stages. Organizers adapt it freely, so treat it as a starting point and publish your own rules.

  • Poets sign up in advance or at the door and are placed in order, often by a random draw
  • The host picks five audience members as judges before the first round and explains the scoring
  • A calibration poet reads first, and the judges score the poem as a warm-up
  • In each round, a poet reads one poem within the time limit and every judge gives a score from 0 to 10
  • The highest and lowest scores are dropped and the middle three are added, for a poem score out of 30
  • Poets with the highest scores move to the next round, and the finals decide the winner

A slam with school students may use fewer rounds, shorter time limits and a different judge pool, such as teachers and local poets. Say who judges in your rules.

Poetry Slam Judging Criteria and Scale

Traditional slam judging doesn't use a formal rubric. Judges are told to score how the poem lands for them, and that tradition is part of the culture. If you want more consistency, or you are running a school or library slam, give judges a short guide with three things to weigh in the single 0 to 10 score.

Example judging guide for the single 0 to 10 score
What to weighWhat judges listen and look forShare of the score
The writingImagery, language, structure, risk and a poem that has something to sayAbout 50 percent
The performanceVoice, pacing, emphasis, presence and how the delivery serves the wordsAbout 30 percent
The effect on the roomWhether the poem moved, surprised or stayed with the listenersAbout 20 percent
Example judging guide for the single 0 to 10 score
Example 0 to 10 scale judges can use
ScoreWhat it means
9.0 to 10Outstanding writing and performance; a poem to remember
8.0 to 8.9A strong poem delivered with confidence
7.0 to 7.9A solid poem with clear strengths and some rough spots
5.0 to 6.9A poem or performance still finding its way
Below 5.0Rarely used; reserved for a poem that did not come together
Example 0 to 10 scale judges can use

Printable Poetry Slam Score Sheet

Judges in a classic slam hold up cards or call out a score, and a scorekeeper writes them on a score sheet. If you want paper judge sheets, use the first template. The second is the scorekeeper's sheet for each round.

How Scores Are Added and Time Penalties

Dropping the high and low scores keeps one judge from deciding a poem. Here is an example round with five judges and a poem that ran 3 minutes 25 seconds, with a rule of 0.5 point off per 10 seconds over a 10-second grace period:

Example: scoring one poem
StepResult
Judges' scores8.5, 9.0, 7.5, 8.8, 9.4
Drop the highest (9.4) and lowest (7.5)8.5, 9.0, 8.8 remain
Add the middle three26.3
Time penalty: 25 seconds over, 10-second grace, so 15 seconds over counts, rounded up to two 10-second blocksminus 1.0
Final poem score25.3 out of 30
Example: scoring one poem
  • Timekeeper starts the clock at the poet's first word and stops it at the last, and shows a one-minute warning card
  • Say whether the penalty applies per 10 seconds or as a flat amount, and publish it with the rules
  • Some slams don't penalize time at all and just cut the poet off; choose one and say which

Instructions for Poetry Slam Judges and Tie-Breaks

  1. 1

    Choose Judges at Random

    Pick five audience members who have no connection to the poets, such as people who haven't signed up and aren't friends of anyone on the list. Pick extras in case someone has to step down.

  2. 2

    Brief the Judges Before Round One

    Explain the 0 to 10 scale, tell judges to use the whole range and to score the poem and performance, not the poet. Warn them that boos and groans for scores are not allowed.

  3. 3

    Run a Calibration Poem

    A calibration poet reads one poem first, judges score it, and the host shows the range. The calibration scores don't count.

  4. 4

    Score Together

    Judges write their score before anyone else shows theirs, and show cards at the same moment on the host's cue.

  5. 5

    Declare Conflicts

    A judge who recognizes a poet from their own circle tells the host, and the host replaces them for that round.

Host Script Outline, Rules and Awards for Organizers

A slam depends on the host more than the sheet. Here is a simple outline for the night, to adapt to your event and run from a run of show template:

  1. Welcome the room, explain what a slam is and thank any sponsors
  2. Explain the rules: original work, time limit and penalty, no props, music or costumes
  3. Introduce the judges, brief them and invite the audience to respond warmly
  4. Bring up the calibration poet and run the calibration score
  5. Introduce each poet by name and let them read; read the scores aloud from the scorekeeper
  6. After each round, announce who moves on, take a short break and start the next round
  7. Announce the winners, hand out prizes and thank the poets

Write the rules on the sign-up sheet and read them at the start: who may enter and how many poems, original work only, the time limit and penalty, no props, music or costumes, content rules for an all-ages room, the number of rounds, how ties are broken and the prizes. The emcee script has wording for the host, and the talent show judging sheet fits a show where poetry is one act among many. For a slam at a larger celebration, see the cultural festival planning guide and festival management software.

How Map D Helps

Schedule the Slam and the Venue in Map D

Map D doesn't score poems, tally slam rounds or run the open mic list. It fits when the slam is part of a larger event, such as a library program, a school festival or a cultural festival: draw the venue in the floor plan editor, mark the stage, sign-up table, seating areas and any vendor booths, put the rounds and the finals on the schedule, send app notifications for round times, and run an audience favorite as a live app poll. Map D doesn't assign guests to seats. The editor is free for one event; publishing and the app need a paid plan.

  • Named areas for the stage, poet sign-up, seating areas and book table, searchable in Find a place on the published map
  • Each round, the break and the finals as sessions on your schedule, on your Homebase and in the app
  • App notifications for doors, round start times and schedule changes, sent now or scheduled
  • Live app polls of 2 to 10 choices on the finals session, for an audience favorite among poets, one vote per signed-in attendee
  • Bookseller, merch and food booths numbered and sold online from the same floor plan
See it on your own floor plan

Stop reading about it. Build one.

Upload the floor plan you already have and place your booths on it yourself, in Map D’s editor. Free to build, no contract, and nothing to install.

900+
Organizers who have run shows on Map D
9,000+
Events powered since 2011
1.8M+
Booths drawn to date

“I am really excited about this. The staff met with me this morning and we all LOVE the platform. People are already filling out their booths.”

· Director, International Trade and Development @ Maine Insurance Agents Association
FAQ

Questions Organizers Ask

What are the judging criteria for a poetry slam?

Judges score a poem from 0 to 10, often with decimals, on how well the poem and the performance work together. The slam format traditionally gives no formal criteria beyond that, though many organizers give judges a short guide covering the writing, the delivery and the effect on the room.

How does a poetry slam work?

In the common format, the host picks five audience members as judges, each poet reads one poem in a round, and each judge holds up a score. The highest and lowest scores are dropped and the middle three are added, for a score out of 30. Poets with the highest totals after several rounds move on or win.

What are the rules of a poetry slam?

A typical rule set is original work only, a 3-minute limit with a penalty for going over, usually after a short grace period, and no props, costumes or musical accompaniment. Rules vary by slam, so publish yours with the sign-up sheet.

What is a calibration poet at a slam?

A calibration poet reads before the competition starts, and the judges score the poem so they hear the range of the scale and the room warms up. The calibration poet's scores don't count, and the judges' scores can be discussed with the audience.

Why do slams drop the high and low scores?

Dropping the highest and lowest scores limits the effect of one judge who is too generous or too harsh. With five judges, the middle three scores decide each poem.