How Wreath Contest Judging Works
A wreath contest is one of the easiest holiday contests to run: wreaths are light, they hang on a wall or a stand, and nobody has to taste, plug in or perform anything. It still needs a sheet, because a bought-and-bowed wreath and a hand-wired natural wreath are not the same thing, and a judge who likes red and gold will otherwise reward red and gold.
| Contest | Usually run by | How it is judged |
|---|---|---|
| Holiday market | Market organizers, downtown associations | Display on a wall or tables, three judges and a People's Choice vote |
| Fundraiser or auction | Churches, schools, nonprofits, hospitals | Entries judged first, then auctioned or sold as a fundraiser |
| Garden club or library | Garden clubs, libraries, historical societies | Classes by material and skill, ribbons by class |
| Business or community | Downtown districts, chambers, HOAs | Wreaths hung on doors or storefronts and judged on site |
| Workplace or school | HR, PTAs, art and horticulture classes | A few judges and a colleague or student vote |
For a contest that covers whole decorated trees, tables and doors, use the Christmas decorating contest judging sheet. This page is for contests where every entry is a wreath.
Wreath Judging Criteria and Points
Five criteria cover what a judge can see on a wreath. The weights below make a 100-point sheet. Publish them with the entry form so makers know what wins.
| Criterion | What judges look for | Points |
|---|---|---|
| Creativity and originality | A fresh idea or a new use of materials, rather than a common design | 25 |
| Craftsmanship and construction | Secure attachments, clean wiring and glue, even fullness, no gaps or loose parts, and it hangs straight | 25 |
| Design and balance | Color, texture, shape and proportion work together; the focal point is clear | 20 |
| Materials and theme | Materials suit the design and the contest theme; creative or recycled materials are used well | 15 |
| Overall visual appeal | The first impression from a few feet away | 15 |
| Total | All criteria | 100 |
| Band | Points | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Beginning | 1 to 8 | Loose pieces, visible glue or wire, uneven or lopsided |
| Developing | 9 to 16 | Mostly secure, with gaps, a crooked hang or messy backing |
| Skilled | 17 to 22 | Clean, secure and even, with only small flaws up close |
| Exceptional | 23 to 25 | Tidy front and back, strong attachments and a balanced shape |
Printable Wreath Contest Score Sheet, Tally and Entry Card
Print one judge sheet per judge per class, a tally sheet for the scorekeeper and an entry card for every wreath. Judges score by entry number only.
Wreath Contest Rules and Display
Most wreath disputes are about store-bought bases, size and whether the maker did the work. Publish rules like these with the entry form. The numbers are examples; set your own to match your display space.
Wreath Contest Classes, Awards and How to Run the Judging
Classes decide who competes against whom. With fewer than 10 entries, one open class plus People's Choice is enough; merge any class with fewer than three entries.
| Class or award | Who or what | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Handmade | Wreaths built from scratch | Usually the biggest class at holiday markets |
| Embellished | A store-bought base, decorated by the maker | Keeps judging fair against handmade work |
| Natural materials | Fresh or dried greens, pine cones, berries, seed pods | Good for garden clubs; check display time |
| Youth | Under 18, by age group | Score against what a strong entry at that age looks like |
| Business or group | Shops, offices, clubs and classrooms | Keep separate from individual entrants |
| Best in show, People's Choice, most creative | Special awards across classes | People's Choice by ballot or an app poll |
- 1
Check In and Number Each Wreath
A volunteer who is not judging checks each wreath against the size and materials rules, gives it a number, and keeps the stub with the maker's name.
- 2
Hang the Display
Group wreaths by class on a wall or rail with space to step back, and cover any names or logos with the entry card.
- 3
Score by Class
Three judges view each wreath from a few feet away, then up close and from the side, and score alone on the sheet. Allow about two minutes per wreath.
- 4
Total and Announce
Two people total the sheets, break ties by the sheet rule, place ribbons and give the emcee the winners.
At a holiday market, the wreath contest pairs well with craft booths and a wreath sale. Our guides on how to plan a holiday market and how to plan a craft fair cover booth layout and vendors, and event signage covers the entry and award signs.
Judge Instructions and Tie-Breakers
- Two people total each sheet and settle any difference before winners are announced
- Ties go to the higher creativity score, then craftsmanship, then a People's Choice round or a shared place, as the rules say
- If a judge steps aside from an entry, average the other judges' scores for it
- Rule breaks, such as a business entering as an individual, are decided by the coordinator, who can move or disqualify the entry
- Common mistakes: judging handmade and bought-base wreaths together, hanging wreaths too high to see and no limit on size
When winners are announced on a stage, the award ceremony script has announcement wording. For another holiday contest at the same market, see the gingerbread house contest judging sheet, which uses the same numbering and entry cards.