How a Wine Competition Works
A wine competition can be a fundraiser for a library, a feature of a harvest festival or a showcase for a regional winery trail. In each case the questions are the same: how to score, how many wines a judge can fairly taste and how to keep it blind. Alcohol rules also differ from one place to the next, so check requirements with your local authority before you announce a date.
| Contest | Usually run by | How it is judged |
|---|---|---|
| Regional wine competition | Wine trail associations, chambers | Blind panels, medal thresholds and flights by style |
| Charity wine tasting contest | Libraries, hospitals, rotary clubs | Guests vote and a small panel awards medals |
| Fair or festival competition | County fairs, harvest festivals | Home winemaker and amateur divisions, volunteer judges |
| Winery club contest | Wine clubs, cooperatives | Members enter, a sommelier judges and a trophy is given |
| Student or training contest | Culinary schools, hospitality programs | Scoring practice on a published rubric |
If entries are beer or cider, try the homebrew competition judging sheet. For a bartender contest, the cocktail competition judging sheet scores drinks made on site.
Wine Scoring Categories, 20-Point and 100-Point Scales
Both sheets below use the same five categories. The 20-point version is quick and easy to add up. The 100-point version fits judges used to consumer reviews. Pick one, publish it and don't switch partway.
| Category | What judges look for | 20-point | 100-point |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appearance | Clarity, color and brightness that fit the style | 2 | 10 |
| Aroma | Clean, expressive nose with no faults such as cork taint or sulfur | 4 | 20 |
| Taste and palate | Balance of fruit, acid, tannin, alcohol and sweetness | 6 | 30 |
| Finish | Length and quality of the aftertaste | 3 | 15 |
| Overall | Typicity, complexity and how well the wine delivers for its style | 5 | 25 |
| Total | All categories | 20 | 100 |
| Medal | 20-point scale | 100-point scale |
|---|---|---|
| Gold | 18 to 20 | 90 and above |
| Silver | 16 to 17.9 | 85 to 89 |
| Bronze | 14 to 15.9 | 80 to 84 |
| No medal | Under 14 | Under 80 |
Printable Wine Judging Sheet and Tally Sheet
Print one sheet per judge per flight. The version below uses the 20-point scale. To switch to 100 points, use the weights in the table above.
How to Run a Wine Competition
Blind tasting is what makes a wine competition credible. These steps keep it clean and keep judges safe.
- 1
Confirm licensing first
Call your local alcohol authority about permits for tasting, pouring and any sales. Rules vary by location, and some require a licensed venue or a licensed server.
- 2
Build flights by style
Group wines by style, such as sparkling, white, rose, red and dessert, and by price if you have commercial entries. Keep each flight to six to eight wines.
- 3
Pour blind in numbered glasses
A steward, not a judge, pours about one ounce of each wine into identical glasses marked with a random number and hides the bottles in paper bags or behind a screen.
- 4
Set up spit buckets and water
Give each judge water, plain crackers or bread, a spit bucket and a pen. Remind them to spit, to pace themselves and to arrange a ride home.
- 5
Score alone
Judges score alone and don't talk until the scorekeeper has every sheet. A short panel discussion after each flight is fine if you want comments.
- 6
Average, apply thresholds, announce
Average each wine's scores, apply the medal thresholds and open the key. Announce medals by flight, then best of show.
Planning the layout for a tasting festival? The event floor plan software page shows how to lay out the judging room, winery booths and water stations.
Wine Competition Rules and Tie-Breaks
| Method | How it works | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Higher palate total | The wine with more palate points across judges wins | Most contests |
| Higher overall total | Used if palate totals are equal | A second tie-break |
| Head judge's call | One named head judge decides between tied wines | Panels of three |
| Panel re-taste | Fresh pours of the tied wines, blind, then a majority vote | Best of show |
| Co-winners | Both wines share the award | Charity and amateur classes |
Keep a guest vote as a separate People's Choice award, and leave medal results out of it. That way the panel's blind scores stand on their own.