Skip to main content
Wine Competition Planning

Wine Competition Judging Sheet and Scoring Scales

A printable wine competition judging sheet with 20-point and 100-point scales, medal thresholds, a tally sheet, blind pour steps and rules for charity and festival contests.

How a Wine Competition Works

A wine competition can be a fundraiser for a library, a feature of a harvest festival or a showcase for a regional winery trail. In each case the questions are the same: how to score, how many wines a judge can fairly taste and how to keep it blind. Alcohol rules also differ from one place to the next, so check requirements with your local authority before you announce a date.

Common kinds of wine competition
ContestUsually run byHow it is judged
Regional wine competitionWine trail associations, chambersBlind panels, medal thresholds and flights by style
Charity wine tasting contestLibraries, hospitals, rotary clubsGuests vote and a small panel awards medals
Fair or festival competitionCounty fairs, harvest festivalsHome winemaker and amateur divisions, volunteer judges
Winery club contestWine clubs, cooperativesMembers enter, a sommelier judges and a trophy is given
Student or training contestCulinary schools, hospitality programsScoring practice on a published rubric
Common kinds of wine competition

If entries are beer or cider, try the homebrew competition judging sheet. For a bartender contest, the cocktail competition judging sheet scores drinks made on site.

Wine Scoring Categories, 20-Point and 100-Point Scales

Both sheets below use the same five categories. The 20-point version is quick and easy to add up. The 100-point version fits judges used to consumer reviews. Pick one, publish it and don't switch partway.

Wine scoring categories on 20-point and 100-point scales
CategoryWhat judges look for20-point100-point
AppearanceClarity, color and brightness that fit the style210
AromaClean, expressive nose with no faults such as cork taint or sulfur420
Taste and palateBalance of fruit, acid, tannin, alcohol and sweetness630
FinishLength and quality of the aftertaste315
OverallTypicity, complexity and how well the wine delivers for its style525
TotalAll categories20100
Wine scoring categories on 20-point and 100-point scales
Medal thresholds to publish before tasting
Medal20-point scale100-point scale
Gold18 to 2090 and above
Silver16 to 17.985 to 89
Bronze14 to 15.980 to 84
No medalUnder 14Under 80
Medal thresholds to publish before tasting

Printable Wine Judging Sheet and Tally Sheet

Print one sheet per judge per flight. The version below uses the 20-point scale. To switch to 100 points, use the weights in the table above.

How to Run a Wine Competition

Blind tasting is what makes a wine competition credible. These steps keep it clean and keep judges safe.

  1. 1

    Confirm licensing first

    Call your local alcohol authority about permits for tasting, pouring and any sales. Rules vary by location, and some require a licensed venue or a licensed server.

  2. 2

    Build flights by style

    Group wines by style, such as sparkling, white, rose, red and dessert, and by price if you have commercial entries. Keep each flight to six to eight wines.

  3. 3

    Pour blind in numbered glasses

    A steward, not a judge, pours about one ounce of each wine into identical glasses marked with a random number and hides the bottles in paper bags or behind a screen.

  4. 4

    Set up spit buckets and water

    Give each judge water, plain crackers or bread, a spit bucket and a pen. Remind them to spit, to pace themselves and to arrange a ride home.

  5. 5

    Score alone

    Judges score alone and don't talk until the scorekeeper has every sheet. A short panel discussion after each flight is fine if you want comments.

  6. 6

    Average, apply thresholds, announce

    Average each wine's scores, apply the medal thresholds and open the key. Announce medals by flight, then best of show.

Planning the layout for a tasting festival? The event floor plan software page shows how to lay out the judging room, winery booths and water stations.

Wine Competition Rules and Tie-Breaks

Ways to break a tie for best of show
MethodHow it worksBest for
Higher palate totalThe wine with more palate points across judges winsMost contests
Higher overall totalUsed if palate totals are equalA second tie-break
Head judge's callOne named head judge decides between tied winesPanels of three
Panel re-tasteFresh pours of the tied wines, blind, then a majority voteBest of show
Co-winnersBoth wines share the awardCharity and amateur classes
Ways to break a tie for best of show

Keep a guest vote as a separate People's Choice award, and leave medal results out of it. That way the panel's blind scores stand on their own.

How Map D Helps

Map the Wine Festival Around the Judging

Map D doesn't score wines, check ID or handle alcohol permits. It fits around the competition: draw the venue in the floor plan editor with a judging room or tasting tables, winery booths, food vendors and the stage, and sell vendor spaces from the same map. Alcohol rules vary by location, so check local licensing before you plan service. The editor is free for one event; publishing, the app and booth sales need a paid plan (from $3,499 per event).

  • Numbered winery and vendor booths, priced by type and sold online from one floor plan
  • Named areas for the judging room, tasting tables, water stations and first aid, searchable on the published map
  • Judging, the awards and tastings as sessions on your schedule, on your Homebase and in the app
  • Live app polls of 2 to 10 choices for a People's Choice vote, one vote per signed-in attendee
  • App notifications for session times, the winners and ride-share reminders, sent now or scheduled
See it on your own floor plan

Stop reading about it. Build one.

Upload the floor plan you already have and place your booths on it yourself, in Map D’s editor. Free to build, no contract, and nothing to install.

900+
Organizers who have run shows on Map D
9,000+
Events powered since 2011
1.8M+
Booths drawn to date

“I am really excited about this. The staff met with me this morning and we all LOVE the platform. People are already filling out their booths.”

· Director, International Trade and Development @ Maine Insurance Agents Association
FAQ

Questions Organizers Ask

How do you judge a wine competition?

Most wine competitions judge appearance, aroma or nose, taste or palate, finish and overall impression. The 20-point sheet gives appearance 2, aroma 4, palate 8 and overall 6, while many use a 100-point scale instead. Judges taste blind, so labels, price and winery don't sway scores.

Should I use a 20-point or 100-point wine score sheet?

The 20-point scale is simple and quick for volunteer panels. The 100-point scale starts at 50 and is familiar to consumers but gives a feeling of precision that tastings rarely have. For a charity or festival contest, either works if the sheet and medal thresholds are published beforehand.

What score earns a gold, silver or bronze medal?

Common thresholds on a 20-point scale are 18 to 20 gold, 16 to 17.9 silver and 14 to 15.9 bronze. On a 100-point scale, gold is often 90 or above, silver 85 to 89 and bronze 80 to 84. Set them before tasting, and note that no medal is also allowed.

How many wines should a judge taste in one flight?

Group wines by style and price, such as sparkling, white, rose, red and dessert, and taste light to heavy. Flights of six to eight wines are the upper limit for most judges. Serve about one ounce per glass at a similar cool or room temperature for the style.

Do I need a license to hold a wine competition?

Rules vary by location. Serving or selling wine at a public event usually needs a permit or a licensed server, and some places restrict who can pour or sell. Confirm requirements with your local alcohol authority and your insurer before you advertise, and require ID checks for anyone tasting.