Skip to main content
Cook-Off Planning

Soup Cook-Off Judging Sheet, Ballot & Rules

A printable 100-point soup cook-off score sheet with taste score bands, a People's Choice ballot, an entry card, categories, slow cooker rules, food safety and judge instructions.

How Soup Cook-Off Judging Works

A soup cook-off is a winter favorite because it is cheap to run, easy to enter and works indoors: every cook brings a slow cooker, and the room does the rest. A judging sheet keeps it fair when the pastor's wife or the CEO enters, and gives a quiet vegetable soup a fair shot against a loaded potato chowder.

Common kinds of soup cook-off
Cook-offUsually run byHow winners are picked
Church or communityChurches, parks departments, libraries, neighborhood groupsThree judges plus a People's Choice ballot for everyone at the supper
WorkplaceHR, social committees, wellness teamsA few judges from other teams and a colleague vote at lunch
FundraiserSchools, PTAs, nonprofits, service clubsTasting kits sold at the door, judges for the main award, vote tickets for People's Choice
Festival or winter eventWinter festivals, downtown associations, breweriesCook tables in a hall or tent, judged categories and a public vote
Common kinds of soup cook-off

Chili usually gets its own contest, with its own criteria for heat and aftertaste. If chili is the main event, use the chili cook-off judging sheet; if you run both, judge them as separate categories with separate sheets.

Soup Contest Judging Criteria and Points

Six criteria cover what judges can see, smell and taste in a small cup. The weights below make a 100-point sheet. Judge each soup against what its style should be: a French onion soup should not be thick, and a chowder should not be thin.

Soup cook-off judging criteria on a 100-point sheet
CriterionWhat judges look forPoints
TasteSeasoned well, balanced, the main flavor clear, no burnt, raw-flour or flat taste35
Texture and consistencyThe right body for the style; vegetables, meat and pasta cooked through but not mushy20
AromaInviting smell that matches the soup10
AppearanceColor, garnish and how appetizing it looks in the cup10
CreativityA fresh idea, family recipe or new twist on a classic15
Overall impressionWould the judge want a full bowl10
TotalAll criteria100
Soup cook-off judging criteria on a 100-point sheet
Score bands for the 35-point taste criterion
BandPointsWhat it means
Needs work1 to 10Bland, too salty, scorched or one flavor drowns out the rest
Good11 to 20Pleasant and well cooked, but plain or slightly off in seasoning
Very good21 to 29Well seasoned and balanced, with clear layers of flavor
Outstanding30 to 35Judges remember it and want the recipe
Score bands for the 35-point taste criterion

Printable Soup Cook-Off Score Sheet, Ballot and Entry Card

Print one sheet per judge per category, an entry card for every soup, and a ballot for every taster. Judges score by entry number only.

Soup Cook-Off Categories

Categories keep a light chicken noodle from losing to a rich cheddar broccoli just because judges taste them side by side. With fewer than 10 entries, one open category plus People's Choice is enough.

Common soup cook-off categories
CategoryIncludesNotes
Broth-basedChicken noodle, minestrone, French onion, pho, tortilla soupJudge clarity and depth of flavor
Cream, chowder and bisqueClam or corn chowder, tomato bisque, potato, cheddar broccoliNeeds careful holding so it doesn't scorch or split
Vegetarian or veganLentil, black bean, butternut squash, vegetableLabel vegan entries clearly for tasters
Hearty or stew-styleBeef stew, gumbo, Zuppa Toscana, split pea with hamDecide where stew ends and soup begins in the rules
Youth or familySoups made by kids or families with kidsGood for school and church events
Common soup cook-off categories
  • Best in show, chosen from the category winners
  • People's Choice, voted by tasters
  • Best family recipe, with a short note on its story
  • Most creative or best new recipe
  • Best table presentation, judged separately from the soup

Soup Cook-Off Rules

Most soup cook-off problems come from power and temperature, not from judging. Write the rules around the slow cooker.

Food Safety, Holding Temperature and Tasting Cups

Rules for serving home-made food to the public vary by state, county and venue. A free church or office cook-off is often treated differently from a public event that sells tasting kits, which commonly needs a temporary food event permit. Check with your local health department and the venue early. This is not legal or food safety advice.

  • Common US guidance is to hold hot soup at 135°F (57°C) or above; keep a food thermometer at the check-in table
  • Set slow cookers to high or warm as needed to hold temperature, and stir often so cream soups don't scorch
  • Give every table its own ladle and a lid that stays on between servings
  • Use single-use tasting cups and spoons, with a trash and spoon bin at every few tables
  • Put the allergen card in front of every soup, facing the tasters
  • End the public tasting after about two to three hours, and have cooks unplug and cool soups before taking them home

Running the Judging and People's Choice

  1. 1

    Check In and Number Each Soup

    A volunteer who is not judging checks each soup's temperature, gives it a number and keeps the stub with the cook's name. Number cards go on the tables facing the room.

  2. 2

    Fill Blind Judging Cups

    Before the public tasting opens, a cup steward ladles each soup into identical judging cups marked only with the entry number and carries them to a separate room or table.

  3. 3

    Taste and Score

    Three judges taste every cup in a category, drink water or eat a plain cracker between cups, and score alone. Cap each panel at about 12 to 15 soups.

  4. 4

    Run the Public Tasting

    Open the tasting with ballots or tickets. Close voting at a fixed time while volunteers total the judges' sheets in another room.

  5. 5

    Count and Announce

    Two people count ballots, settle ties and announce category winners, best in show and People's Choice from the front of the room.

At a fundraiser, the money usually comes from tasting kits sold at the door, such as a bowl, spoon and ballot for a set price, plus extra vote tickets, a bread or dessert table and sponsor tables. Our fundraising event ideas and church event ideas cover formats that pair well with a soup supper, and winter event ideas has more for the season.

Judge Instructions and Tie-Breakers

  • Two people total each sheet and settle any difference before winners are announced
  • Ties go to the higher taste score, then texture, then a discussion among the judges
  • People's Choice ties go to a coin toss or a shared award, decided in the rules
  • If a judge steps aside from an entry, average the other judges' scores for it
  • Common mistakes: too many cookers on one circuit, judging after the soup has sat for hours, and no closing time for the vote

When winners are announced on a stage, the award ceremony script has announcement wording. For a summer follow-up, the salsa contest judging sheet uses the same blind cups and ballot.

How Map D Helps

Run Cook Tables and the Map in Map D

A small church or office soup cook-off doesn't need Map D: a table, slow cookers and a ballot box work fine. It fits when the cook-off is part of a larger community event, winter festival or fundraiser with cook tables, sponsors and vendors: draw the hall or grounds in the floor plan editor, number every cook table, and let teams pick a table and pay their entry fee online. Map D doesn't run the tasting, tally the judges' scores or take donations. The editor is free for one event; publishing, the app and online sales need a paid plan.

  • Numbered cook tables, so the number on the map matches the table where tasters vote
  • Booth types for cook tables, sponsor tables and vendors, each with its own price and color
  • Checkout questions for team name, category and power needs, with a file upload for a permit or food handler card
  • Find a place on the published map, on your Homebase and in the app, for cook tables, the ballot box and the judging room
  • Live app polls of 2 to 10 choices on the awards session, for a People's Choice vote among finalists, one vote per signed-in attendee
  • App notifications for tasting hours, the People's Choice cutoff and the awards, sent now or scheduled
See it on your own floor plan

Stop reading about it. Build one.

Upload the floor plan you already have and place your booths on it yourself, in Map D’s editor. Free to build, no contract, and nothing to install.

900+
Organizers who have run shows on Map D
9,000+
Events powered since 2011
1.8M+
Booths drawn to date

“I am really excited about this. The staff met with me this morning and we all LOVE the platform. People are already filling out their booths.”

· Director, International Trade and Development @ Maine Insurance Agents Association
FAQ

Questions Organizers Ask

What are the judging criteria for a soup cook-off?

Most soup cook-offs score taste, texture and consistency, aroma, appearance and creativity, with taste worth the most. Texture means the right body for the style: a clear broth, a smooth bisque or a chunky chowder with vegetables cooked through but not mushy.

How do you judge a soup cook-off?

A volunteer who is not judging ladles each soup into identical cups marked only with an entry number. Judges taste every cup in a category, drink water or eat a plain cracker between cups, and score alone on the same sheet. Two people total the sheets.

How does a People's Choice soup ballot work?

Give each taster one ballot, or one ticket, with their tasting cups or spoons. Tasters write the entry number of their favorite soup, or drop their ticket in the jar at that soup's table, and volunteers count at a fixed closing time. Fundraisers often sell extra vote tickets.

What are the rules for a soup cook-off?

Typical rules ask for a set amount of soup, often 2 to 4 quarts, in a slow cooker or roaster, fully cooked and hot on arrival, with an ingredient and allergen card. Say what categories exist, whether chili counts, and that cooks bring their own ladle and extension cord if allowed.

How much soup should each cook bring?

Plan on a 2 to 3 ounce tasting cup per soup per taster. With ten soups, a 3-quart slow cooker serves about 30 to 40 tasters, so ask for more soup, or fewer cups per taster, if you expect a big crowd.