How Quilts Are Judged
A quilt show at a guild or county fair might hang a hand-quilted Double Wedding Ring next to a longarm-quilted modern wall piece. A judging sheet lets a judge compare entries within a category on the same terms, and the comment sheet that goes back to each quilter is often valued more than the ribbon.
- Quilts are entered by a deadline with an entry form and photo, assigned a number and a category, and dropped off before the show
- Judging happens before the show opens, usually in a closed room, with a judge, a scribe and two or more white-glove handlers
- The judge scores or ranks each quilt in a category and dictates comments, which the scribe writes on the comment sheet
- Ribbons go to first, second and third in each category, with honorable mentions, Best of Show and specialty awards
- Visitors vote for Viewer's Choice during the show, separate from the judged awards
Some guilds use points, as below. Others use an elimination method, where the judge sorts each category into keep and set-aside piles and ranks the remaining quilts, then writes comments on every entry. Both work; points are easier to explain to new entrants.
Quilt Judging Criteria and Points
Workmanship carries most of the points on a quilt judging sheet. Score construction on the technique the quilt uses, piecing, applique or both, rather than penalizing a quilt for not using one.
| Criterion | What judges look for | Points |
|---|---|---|
| General appearance | Visual impact, clean and free of marks, pet hair and odors, lies flat and hangs straight | 20 |
| Design and color | Composition, balance, use of color and value, fabric choices and the quilting design suiting the top | 20 |
| Construction: piecing and applique | Matching points and seams, accurate blocks, smooth applique edges and curves, invisible or even stitches | 20 |
| Quilting | Even stitch length and tension, consistent density across the quilt, no puckers or tucks, starts and stops hidden | 25 |
| Finishing | Binding full and even, mitered or square corners, straight edges, a label and a hanging sleeve if required | 15 |
| Total | All criteria | 100 |
| Band | Points | Typical result |
|---|---|---|
| Excellent | 90 to 100 | Eligible for first place and Best of Show |
| Very good | 80 to 89 | Eligible for second or third place |
| Good | 70 to 79 | Eligible for honorable mention |
| Developing | Below 70 | Comment sheet with suggestions, no ribbon |
Printable Quilt Show Judging Form
Use one sheet per quilt. The scribe fills it in as the judge talks, and the sheet goes back to the quilter after the show.
Quilt Show Categories
Categories put quilts of similar size and technique together. Size limits are often set by perimeter, the total length of all four sides. The limits below are examples; set your own and publish them on the entry form.
| Category | What it covers | Example size rule |
|---|---|---|
| Large bed quilt | Quilts made to fit a full, queen or king bed | Perimeter over 280 inches |
| Small bed quilt | Twin, crib and lap quilts | Perimeter 200 to 280 inches |
| Wall quilt | Quilts made to hang, pieced or applique | Perimeter under 200 inches |
| Art quilt | Original designs that explore an idea, technique or surface treatment | Any size, often with a minimum |
| Modern | Quilts in a modern style, with bold color, negative space or improv piecing | Any size |
| Miniature | Small-scale quilts with reduced block sizes | Often under 24 inches on each side |
| Group quilt | Quilts made by three or more people | Any size |
| Two-person quilt | One person makes the top, another quilts it | Any size |
| Youth | Quilts made by entrants under a set age, often 18 | Any size |
| First-time entrant | Quilters who have never entered a judged show | Any size |
- Split large categories by quilting method: hand, domestic machine, and longarm, with computer-guided quilting in its own category or disclosed on the form
- Credit both the maker and the quilter on the entry form and display card
- Set a minimum number of entries to award a category, and merge small ones
- Decide whether quilts that won a ribbon at an earlier show of yours can enter again
White-Glove Judging Instructions and Tie-Breaks
- 1
White Gloves Only
The judge, scribe and handlers wear clean white cotton gloves. No food, drinks or pens near the quilts; the scribe works at a separate table.
- 2
Handlers Move the Quilt
Two handlers lay each quilt on a clean, sheet-covered table or hold it up, then fold back corners and turn it so the judge can see the back, binding and edges.
- 3
Keep It Anonymous
Cover the maker's label and any name with paper and painter's tape, or fold it under, so the judge sees only the entry number.
- 4
See the Whole Category First
The judge looks at a whole category before scoring, so the first quilt isn't scored on a different scale than the last.
- 5
Comment on Every Quilt
Comments name something that works well and one thing to consider, in plain and kind language. The quilter will read every word.
- 6
Declare Conflicts
If the judge has a family member, student or close friend in a category, another judge scores those quilts or the guild notes the conflict on the form.
Entry, Rules and Awards for Organizers
- Entry form: maker and quilter names, contact, category, size, techniques used, quilting method, a photo, whether the quilt is for sale, and a short story about the quilt for the display card
- Rules: quilts must be finished, clean and labeled; a hanging sleeve of a set width, commonly 4 inches, sewn to the top back; a limit on entries per person; and whether the quilt must be completed within a set number of years
- Drop-off and pick-up: fixed times, a claim ticket, and a rule that no quilt leaves before the show closes
- Care and insurance: say how quilts are stored and handled, and that owners insure their own quilts; check with your venue and insurer about coverage
- Awards: ribbons for first through third and honorable mention in each category, Best of Show, Judge's Choice, Viewer's Choice, and specialty awards such as best hand quilting, best machine quilting or best use of color
Hang ribbon winners on the display rows before doors open, and post Viewer's Choice at a set time on the last day. Guild shows often fund themselves with a merchant mall; the vendor market layout guide covers aisle and booth spacing, and event floor plan software covers drawing the display rows and booths together. The art contest judging rubric and the craft fair planning guide cover other judged displays at the same kind of event.